Queer historical romance is having a measurable moment. U.S. sales of LGBTQ fiction hit an all-time high of 6.1 million units in the twelve months ending May 2023 — up 11 percent year over year and a 173 percent surge against the 2019 pre-pandemic benchmark, according to market researcher Circana. The strongest engine inside that growth is adult romance, and the books leading readers into the genre stretch from the ancient worlds of A.J. Demas to twentieth-century New York City. Here is where to start, and why the shelf is expanding.

The Queer Historical Romance Boom: A Cultural Phenomenon

Olivia Waite, writing for The New York Times in February 2025, described the peculiar emotional weight of assembling such a list: "Writing a list of queer historical romances feels half like writing a manifesto and half like writing a eulogy." Her framing captures the genre's cultural work — these are stories that let queer people be happy on the page, in eras that historically denied them that possibility.

Waite's worry is that tragedy will again be made "the central queer experience," and her antidote is the genre itself: "Seeing queer people build their own happiness brick by brick no matter what the world thinks of them nourishes something in me." The books she recommends are, in her words, "stories that defy tragedy and laugh in the face of shame, of people successfully claiming joy — as is their right."

What makes the current boom more than a critical enthusiasm is that it shows up in checkout data, not just in essays. Romance is the single largest contributor to the LGBTQ fiction category's expansion, and the historical wing of the genre has become one of its most visible entry points — a fact that helps explain why mainstream outlets are now publishing starter packs at all.

Why Now? Data-Backed Trends Driving Popularity

The numbers come from Circana, a market research firm that tracks U.S. book sales. Its June 2023 analysis found that LGBTQ romance novels alone sold 1 million units in the twelve months ending May 2023 — a 40 percent increase over the corresponding period a year earlier — and that romance accounted for 30 percent of the overall growth in LGBTQ subjects. The romance analysis site Romancing the Data, reviewing those figures alongside its own Google Trends and Kindle Store research, concluded that the category's rise is real and sustained rather than a temporary spike.

Circana itself connected the surge to its cultural context: the growth "comes at a critical time when reports of book bans have surged, predominantly targeting books written by or about the LGBTQ community and people of color." Readers, in other words, appear to be buying more of exactly what some institutions are trying to restrict. The growth spans fantasy, thrillers, science fiction, and horror, but romance's dominance suggests the demand is specifically for love stories with happy endings — the genre's foundational promise.

One caveat matters for precision: Circana tracks LGBTQ fiction and LGBTQ romance as whole categories, not the queer historical romance subgenre separately. The starter-pack era in historical romance is riding a broader wave, and the public data described here covers sales through May 2023, with interest metrics from 2022 onward. Within that wave, the historical subgenre's rise is visible in what critics and retailers are championing, even though no standalone sales figure isolates it.