Book bans in the United States have been driven by four recurring motivations—political and religious dissent, obscenity and morality, scientific and ideological conflict, and, most recently, race and identity—and while the targets have changed dramatically since 1637, the underlying impulse to control access to knowledge has not. That is the central finding that emerges from historical accounts and recent research on school library challenges: authorities once burned books as heresy, then prosecuted them as obscenity, and now remove them from shelves over contested content about race, gender, and sexuality. What follows traces each category, then compares them side by side.

The Enduring Practice of Book Censorship

Censorship, as National Geographic has documented, is as old as writing itself, though its targets have shifted over the centuries. In the American colonies, the earliest suppression efforts were spurred by religious leaders, and Britain brought a long-standing tradition of book censorship with it when it founded its territories. A paper published in an American Library Association journal frames the same continuity: book censorship has a vast history in the United States, with obscenity laws playing a major role for decades alongside LGBTQ+ themes, religious values, race, and political ideology. Recent peer-reviewed research on school bans confirms the practice is anything but foreign, noting that U.S. schools and libraries have banned books with some regularity for the past two centuries—before a drastic increase in the 2021–2022 school year.

Political and Religious Dissent: Early Targets of Suppression

The first book ban on American soil was, by the standards of its time, an act of regime protection. According to a Harvard Library research guide, Thomas Morton's New English Canaan, published in 1637 in what is now Quincy, Massachusetts, was banned by the Puritan government because it was considered a harsh and heretical critique of Puritan customs and power structures. The justification was explicit: the text threatened both religious conformity and the governing order built upon it. Religious institutions elsewhere have long done the same—historical examples include the Catholic Church's Index Librorum Prohibitorum and the ban on Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses—though such bans did not always carry legal force.

The pattern persists into the present in recognizably similar form. Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, as the Freedom Forum records, has been challenged in public schools for its treatment of sex and exploitation and for its criticisms of religion in government. In 2023, parents in South Carolina called for its removal after state legislators cited the book during a debate over a proposed abortion ban—though that challenge failed and the book stayed on shelves. The justification has evolved from heresy to classroom appropriateness, but the underlying charge, that a book illegitimately attacks the entanglement of religion and governance, remains recognizable across nearly four centuries.

Obscenity and Morality: The Rise of Social Control

Moral censorship acquired federal teeth in 1873. That year, as National Geographic recounts, the Comstock Act made it illegal to possess "obscene" or "immoral" texts or articles or to send them through the mail. Championed by moral crusader Anthony Comstock, the law was designed to ban content about sexuality and birth control, which was then widely available by mail order. This was a decisive shift: suppression no longer required a colonial government or a church, only a postal inspector enforcing a federal statute.

The concern with obscenity, according to a survey of censorship history, appears to have begun in the mid-19th century, when the rise of the middle class with evangelical backgrounds brought renewed anxiety about materials touching on sexuality, race, drugs, or social standing. The vocabulary has changed, but the impulse survives. In the American Library Association's yearly book challenge reports, "sexually explicit" subject matter remains one of the most common reasons for challenges—the same justification Anthony Comstock used, now applied to school library shelves rather than the mail.

Scientific and Ideological Conflict: Challenging Established Norms

A third strand runs through conflicts over ideas themselves rather than governance or morality. Recent academic research on school book bans situates two centuries of American banning within a broader clash in which traditional norms were challenged by modernist and scientific thought. Books that conflicted with religious values or carried unsettling scientific claims became recurring targets as curricula and library collections became battlegrounds over what students should be permitted to encounter. The category is distinctive because the contested object is epistemic: the objection is not that a book is obscene or seditious, but that it advances a way of understanding the world that authorities find threatening. In the contemporary context, that same dynamic appears in disputes over critical race theory and inclusive gender theory, where the complaint is ideological content itself rather than any single passage.

Race and Identity: Contemporary Battlegrounds

The newest focus of censorship is also, in one telling, the oldest. According to Brenda Álvarez, writing in the National Education Association's NEA Today, the earliest American book bans in a meaningful sense began with laws designed to keep enslaved people illiterate—lawmakers banned something even more fundamental than any title: the ability of Black Americans to read at all. Her article argues that bans throughout U.S. history carry a distinctly racist and homophobic narrative, and that today's bans center on books that lift up Black, LGBTQ+, and Indigenous voices.

Recent data bear out the pattern. Journalists documenting the post-2021 rise in bans have noted that removals directed against profanity, violence, and sexual content disproportionately target books with LGBTQ+ and Black characters, while the vast majority of bans follow larger debates about critical race theory, LGBTQ+ perspectives, and inclusive gender theory in curricula. Aaron Kubo, a Hawai'i middle school social studies teacher quoted in the NEA piece, put the stakes plainly: "Books are where we keep knowledge. When students realize this, … they begin to understand what they can do with it: Gain power, … change the world."

A Comparative Look at Book Censorship Motivations

The table below categorizes documented bans by their primary justification, drawing the stated rationale and representative examples from historical accounts and recent challenge data. Read across the rows to see how the enforcement mechanism and the target shift together over time—from heresy verdicts to federal postal law to school board decisions.

Four categories of book censorship, their stated justifications, and representative examples
CategoryCore JustificationRepresentative Examples
Political & Religious Dissent Suppress ideas that challenge established governmental or religious authority; early bans cited "heretical critique" and later "criticisms of religion in government." Thomas Morton's New English Canaan (1637), banned by the Puritan government; The Handmaid's Tale, challenged in schools, including a 2023 South Carolina attempt that failed.
Obscenity & Morality Enforce perceived public morality, especially around sexuality; the concern rose in the mid-19th century with the evangelical middle class and persists as "sexually explicit" complaints. Texts targeted under the 1873 Comstock Act, which criminalized possessing or mailing "obscene" or "immoral" materials, including content on sexuality and birth control.
Scientific & Ideological Conflict Resist ideas challenging traditional norms, particularly modernist and scientific thought conflicting with religious values; a factor in U.S. schools and libraries for two centuries. The historical conflict is well documented, but specific representative titles for this category are not established in the sources compared here.
Race & Identity Control access to knowledge and suppress voices related to race, gender, and sexuality—running from laws keeping enslaved people illiterate to today's challenges to Black, LGBTQ+, and Indigenous voices. Books with LGBTQ+ and Black characters, frequently challenged for "sexually explicit" subject matter, profanity, or violence amid debates over critical race theory and inclusive gender theory.

Two features of this comparison deserve emphasis. First, the enforcement venue has migrated from church and colonial government to Congress to local school boards, making censorship simultaneously less absolute and more frequent. Second, the justifications overlap deliberately: contemporary challenges to books about race and identity most often cite sexual content, which suggests the moral vocabulary of the Comstock era is being applied to a new set of targets.

The Evolving Landscape of Censorship

What the comparison reveals is continuity wearing changing costumes. The Puritan suppression of Morton, the Comstock prosecutions, and the current wave of school library challenges all share a single underlying logic: a gatekeeper deciding which readers may encounter which ideas. National Geographic's history frames the shifts as moving targets across centuries; the ALA-published paper tracks the same evolution through obscenity law, religious values, race, and political ideology; and the NEA account locates the thread even earlier, in the regulation of literacy itself. The focus has moved from heresy, to obscenity, to identity—but in each phase, the contested question was who gets access to knowledge.

Understanding the Enduring Battle for Literary Freedom

Readers should recognize that while the specific targets of book bans evolve, the underlying motivations to control knowledge and ideas persist across historical periods. The practical takeaway from this comparison is a diagnostic habit: when a book is challenged today, ask which of the four justifications is actually doing the work, because the stated reason—"sexually explicit," "age-inappropriate," "ideological"—often conceals the category it belongs to.

The measurable indicator to watch is continued public discourse and challenges regarding books in schools and libraries, particularly those addressing identity and social issues; the ALA's yearly challenge reports and the trajectory of disputes over critical race theory and LGBTQ+ perspectives in curricula are the concrete record of whether the current wave crests or recedes. The 2023 South Carolina challenge that failed, and the drastic increase in bans during the 2021–2022 school year that preceded it, mark both poles of what readers can observe next.

2K views · 42 reactions | “ABCs of Book Banning,” a new documentary, looks at how book bans affect everyone — including eight-year-old RidleTo provide a contemporary perspective on the impact of book bans on individuals, particularly children, and to underscore the ongoing relevance of the issue.View original on Facebook

Sources